• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to after header navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Clean Feed

Clean Feed

  • Timeline
  • News
  • Opinion
  • PresWatch
  • Bloopers
  • News+
  • Resources
  • Rewind
  • Showreel
  • Studio A
  • TX
  • Webfax

Is the BBC Red Button Text service serving a useful purpose?

Posted on 14th April 2024
By Andrew Nairn
Last updated on 14th April 2024
Filed under Opinion

Is it time for the BBC’s Red Button Text service to be put out of its misery?

The service – with faint echoes of the beloved Ceefax – was due to close 4 years ago.

It was unexpectedly spared execution because of the pandemic.

Understandably the need to ensure accurate information was made as widely available as possible in a dire emergency took precedence.

It was argued that many who still used the service did not have internet access.

But now the emergency has passed. Life is back to normal.

There is no original journalism on the Red Button Text service. Generally it is made up of the first four paragraphs of stories from the BBC website.

Some of them make no sense on the red button service.

There was a prime example on Saturday.

The BBC website carried an enjoyable piece looking back at the famous motorway service chain Little Chef. It was featured on the BBC News homepage.

But on the red button service it looked ridiculous.

It featured as a top headline and the first four paragraphs in isolation didn’t tell a story.

Does anyone actually look at the service which is being broadcast? Is it simply produced automatically?

PICTURED: a selection of pages from the BBC Red Button Text service (Sky platform). DATE: 14th April 2024. COPYRIGHT: BBC.

It is being killed off by stealth anyway. It is not supported by newer satellite boxes and does not feature on cable.

Its main platform is Freeview.

I will always believe that the BBC needs to be mindful of the digitally disadvantaged and the vulnerable in a way that commercial broadcasters are not.

It is right that the BBC was very cautious about shutting down SD satellite services and appears to be adopting a very careful approach to ending AM radio transmission.

I also cannot envisage BBC Freeview transmission ending in the foreseeable future (i.e., the next 10 to 15 years) even if Freely proves a big success and some may push for an end to DTT.

But about the only thing that can be said in defence of the legacy red button service is that it must be costing practically nothing.

If the BBC, legitimately, believes this service still has some value to part of the audience then it needs to actually take the service seriously again.

If nothing else, could someone be made operationally and editorially responsible for what actually appears on it? There’s no need to create a job and spend money. Make it the responsibility of someone on a particular shift.

Choose the stories that work for the service, place them in an appropriate order and ensure they make sense!

Otherwise the plug should be pulled as soon as possible.

Related

Acknowledgements

Related

FEATURE IMAGE:

PICTURED: weather page on the BBC Red Button Text service. COPYRIGHT: BBC.

Related

Related

Sidebar

Tags: BBC, BBC Red Button, Red Button Text Services

Follow Us on Bluesky

Bluesky is the only social media platform where you'll find regular updates from The TV Room.

You'll find us here.

Pres Café Forum



Join in the discussion about TV presentation and branding.

TV Pres Updates



The latest updates from a number of presentation-related websites.

Latest updates over on: Rewind

Happy Days close and Channel 4 continuity including programme promotions for Equinox, Jake’s Progress and Absolutely Animals followed by Brookside opening (23rd September 1995)

Happy Days close and Channel 4 continuity including programme promotions for Equinox, Jake’s Progress and Absolutely Animals followed by Brookside opening (23rd September 1995)

Mister Magoo and Channel 4 continuity including programme promotion for Wild Britain followed by Happy Days opening (23rd September 1995)

Mister Magoo and Channel 4 continuity including programme promotion for Wild Britain followed by Happy Days opening (23rd September 1995)

About This Site · Contact Us · FAQ · Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions

Unless otherwise indicated material featured on this site is © 2025 The TV Room.

Established in 1999, The TV Room is not affiliated with any broadcaster, production company or design/marketing/talent agency.

Back to top

 

Loading Comments...